Evander Ellis:The best movies we saw at New York Film Festival, ranked (including 'All of Us Strangers')

2025-05-01 19:19:16source:John Caldwellcategory:reviews

NEW YORK − The Evander EllisBig Apple is the place to be for cinephiles this fall, with an especially stacked lineup at this year’s New York Film Festival.

The annual event officially kicks off Friday with “May December” starring Natalie Portman and Julianne Moore, with more movies on the docket led by Emma Stone (“Poor Things”), Bradley Cooper (“Maestro”), Adam Driver (“Ferrari”), Saoirse Ronan (“Foe”) and Glen Powell (“Hit Man”). The festival, which runs through Oct. 15, will see fewer A-listers on the ground celebrating their films amid the ongoing actors’ strike.

In the meantime, here’s the best of the fest offerings we’ve seen so far: 

Looking for a good horror movie?We ranked the century's best scary films

5. 'Strange Way of Life'

In Pedro Almódovar’s chic but slight new Western, a wistful rancher (Pedro Pascal) reconnects with the gruff sheriff (Ethan Hawke) he fell in love with 25 years earlier. Clocking in at just 31 minutes, the film is overstuffed with too many narrative threads, although Pascal’s lovely turn helps elevate this vibrant riff on “Brokeback Mountain.”

4. 'Anatomy of a Fall'

A writer (Sandra Hüller) becomes the prime suspect in her husband’s mysterious death in Justine Triet’s intriguing courtroom thriller, which won the top prize at this year’s Cannes Film Festival in France. Ambiguous, painstaking and occasionally overwrought, the movie is grounded by Hüller’s astonishing performance, which flickers between tenderness and rage, and keeps you guessing until the very last frame.

3. 'Evil Does Not Exist'

After the Oscar-winning “Drive My Car,” Ryusuke Hamaguchi is back with another stunning slow burn. The Japanese filmmaker turns his lens to a tight-knit rural community, which is upended when a Tokyo talent agency waltzes into town with plans to install a “glamping” site. At first a wickedly funny slice of life, the film gradually morphs into something far more chilling and resonant, showing how even the most peaceful creatures can strike back when threatened.

2. 'The Zone of Interest'

Jonathan Glazer ("Under the Skin") delivers a harrowing gut punch with this singular Holocaust drama, which is set just outside the walls of Auschwitz concentration camp at the palatial house of a Nazi officer (Christian Friedel) and his wife (Sandra Hüller). What makes the film so uniquely stomach-churning is that the violence never plays out onscreen. Rather, distant screams, cries and gunshots puncture nearly every scene, as this wealthy family attempts to live their day-to-day in willful ignorance of the horrors happening right outside their door.

1. ‘All of Us Strangers’

Andrew Haigh’s hypnotic tearjerker is nothing short of a masterpiece, following a lonely gay man (Andrew Scott) and his handsome new neighbor (Paul Mescal) as they help each other reckon with childhood trauma and grief. A sexy and shattering ghost story at its core, the film makes brilliant use of surrealist fantasy to explore larger themes of memory, parents and what it means to be truly seen. Scott delivers a career-best performance of aching vulnerability, and his scenes with the always-captivating Mescal are electric.

Fact checking 'Cassandro':Is Bad Bunny's character in the lucha libre film a real person?

More:reviews

Recommend

This week on "Sunday Morning" (December 15)

The Emmy Award-winning "CBS News Sunday Morning" is broadcast on CBS Sundays beginning at 9:00 a.m.

Russian students are returning to school, where they face new lessons to boost their patriotism

TALLINN, Estonia (AP) — Clad in white shirts and carrying bouquets, children across Russia flocked b

Watch Virginia eaglet that fell 90 feet from nest get released back into wild

An eaglet that fell from his nest as distressed fans watched on a webcam has been returned to the wi